Rethinking the Assessment of Decision-Making Capacity and Making

Treatment-Related Decisions


Juliana Kan Yin Li


An accurate determination of an individual’s decision-making capacity is fundamental to obtaining informed consent for medical treatment, as it allows clinicians to balance respect for patients’ autonomy with the best interests of patients. Despite the increasing demand for assessments of patients’ capacity, healthcare professionals find this task complex and challenging. Currently, assessments are largely based on patients’ cognitive ability and do not sufficiently take into account other factors that influence patients’ judgment. Furthermore, it is important to assess for and treat modifiable factors that impair decision-making capabilities, and to have guidance on when it is appropriate to delay treatment-related decisions. This article will review current methods for assessing capacity, highlight other factors to consider in the decision-making process, and propose an enhanced framework to guide clinicians in making timely and prudent treatment-related decisions for patients with impaired capacity.




This .pdf file may be viewed, downloaded, and/or printed for personal use only.

Access to this .pdf will end when you close the file.


Terms and conditions:

You have purchased one-time access to a .pdf of this article.

Purchasers may not:

• Distribute a copy of the article, online or in print, without the express written permission of JCE.

• Post the article online in any way.
• Charge another party for a copy of the article.


Click here to return to The Journal of Clinical Ethics homepage.